Books vs Movies?
What is more effective?
What to choose?
In this short article, 1minutobook will study this exciting question: books vs movies.
I think both formats are great; each serves its own purpose and each format has its advantages and disadvantages.
Books: Pros
Books train our brains and develop thinking processes
We all know that reading is good for us. But what we don’t always realize is how much it actually helps us think. Whether it’s books or movies, there’s no denying that both genres help expand one’s perspective and improve overall mental capabilities. In fact, according to research conducted by the American Psychological Association, “books or movies teach us about ourselves, others, society, and culture.”
Bill Gates reads 75 books per annum on average. He says he doesn’t read fiction, though. Instead, he prefers nonfiction. His favorite authors include Malcolm Gladwell, Nassim Nicholas Taleb, and Robert Greene. And while most people might prefer watching movies over reading books, the former genre does offer unique benefits. For example, movies allow us to see things from different perspectives. They give us insight into how people think, feel, and behave. As such, they enable us to learn more about ourselves and those around us.
Toni Robbins is another person who loves reading. She devours novels like nobody else. Her favorites include Gone Girl by Gillian Flynn, The Martian by Andy Weir, and The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern. Robbins’ favorite book is probably The Fault in Our Stars by John Green. When she isn’t reading, Robbins enjoys writing, traveling, and spending time with her family.
Books may enrich your experience
The power of words is something that everyone knows intuitively. But it is worth remembering that there are different types of words, depending on how they are used. For example, while a book can take us away to another world, a movie cannot do the same thing. A book gives us a chance to immerse ourselves into someone else’s life, whereas a movie lets us see what happens on screen. In addition, a book allows us to imagine things that don’t exist, whereas a movie doesn’t allow us to do that.
Words are much more powerful than movie images. They can evoke strong feelings in you, giving you the opportunity to connect with others and make yourself understood better. If we think about the most popular books and movies, we’ll notice that they tend to be written by great authors and directed by talented directors. These pieces of art may inspire us, change our lives, and enrich our experience.
Books help you to dive into the culture
If you’re trying to learn about another culture, it might be best to start with a book. There are several reasons why. First, books aren’t just written by experts in the field; they’re written by authors who live there. Second, books are easy to carry around and read anywhere. Third, they’re portable. And fourth, they’re cheap.
In contrast, watching movies isn’t always the most effective way to get a feel for another culture. You’ll notice cultural differences in how things look, sound, and even smell. But you won’t notice those differences unless you actually try to experience them.
Books are portable
A book is simply a collection of words printed on paper. But books aren’t just physical objects; they’re also digital files stored on a computer. And because of how easily books can be transported around the world, they’re often used as gifts — especially during holidays like Valentine’s Day and Mother’s Day.
But what if there was something better? What if you could carry a book with you wherever you went without having to worry about batteries dying, screens breaking, or losing your place while reading? Well, now there is.
In fact, there are many ways to enjoy a book without needing a traditional device. For instance, you can use a Kindle Paperwhite e-reader, an iPad, or even a smartphone to read your favorite books. Or you might prefer to listen to audiobooks. If you do decide to buy a book, you’ll find plenty of options to choose from. Amazon offers thousands of different types of books in every genre imaginable. There are some great classics, such as “The Great Gatsby,” and newer releases, including “Game of Thrones.”
Books allow better understand a characters
If you read books, you know how important it is to immerse yourself into the world of a book. You become one with the characters, their emotions, their thoughts, and their goals. You feel what they feel, think what they think, and act like them. This is why books are such great ways to learn about life.
With all this knowledge inherently embedded within the text, understanding the main characters’ actions and motivations is never difficult. However, with movies, there are times when you find yourself confused about what the characters are thinking. They say something, but do you really know what they mean? Or did they just say it because someone told them to?
In addition, many people are distracted by beautiful acting and fantastic special effects. So they lose sight of what is truly at the heart: the plot and character development. And that is true even if they are watching a good film.
Word Play doesn’t translate
The Bard’s plays are considered classics, but many people don’t understand why. “Romeo and Juliet,” written in 1597, is one example. In it, the lovers speak in verse, and even though it’s been translated into English, much of the original language is lost.
We can hear the cadence and rhythm of the dialogue. But still, we can’t fully enjoy the consistent pattern throughout each scene. For instance, there’s the ironic tone, the sarcastic humor, and the emotional undertones.
Modern audiences also fail to grasp the full meaning of words like “fatal,” “dreadful,” “happily married,” and others. So the irony, sarcasm and other subtleties are lost.
Books allow better understand a characters
The length of a book is determined by how much space it takes up. A book about a person’s life might take up hundreds of pages because there are lots of details. On the other hand, a novel about a robot might only take up a few hundred pages. There are a lot fewer details to cover.
In general, longer books contain more information. They’re often called “page-turners.” However, some people prefer shorter books. If you want to read something really short, try reading a story online.
Word Play doesn’t translate
Shakespeare wrote his plays in English, but he didn’t write them in English. He wrote them in verse. And it’s one of the things that make his work timeless. But there’s no way to capture the poetry of a play in prose. Which is why it’s difficult to bring Shakespeare’s works to life in film or TV.
The Bard’s words aren’t always easy to understand, even though they’re written in plain English. They use figurative language and complex sentence structures. So how do you translate those into something that can be understood by modern audiences?
Books are richer for details
The number of words we read per day continues to grow.
According to a study conducted by Oxford University Press, the average person reads about 5,500 words every day. This figure includes both fiction and nonfiction.
But there is a difference between reading a novel and a short story. A novel is typically longer than 500 pages. On the other hand, a short story might only consist of one hundred pages.
A lot of people believe that books are better because you don’t lose anything when cutting out certain parts. They think that it’s like watching a movie where you see everything that happens.
However, this isn’t true. In fact, many books are much shorter than what most people assume. For example, “Martian” by Andy Weir consists of just over a hundred pages. However, he managed to include a lot of detail.
In his book, Weir describes how the crew of the spaceship Ares 3 had to prepare themselves for landing on Mars. He explains how the astronauts ate food that didn’t taste good, how they trained for months to survive on the planet, and even tells us how they built their spacesuits.
Weir says that he wanted to write a book that was different from other science fiction stories. Instead of focusing on space travel and aliens, he chose to focus on the everyday life of the crew.
More hours of entertainment
The average length of a film is 2 hours. This means that you can watch it four times over without getting bored. A book lasts 8 hours. You can read it eight times and still enjoy yourself. So what does that mean? Well, it means that there are more hours of enjoyment for you to look forward to.
This is why I love reading books. They give me more hours of entertainment than films do. And I know that this is true because I have done the math myself.
I recently bought a Kindle eBook reader. Now I can read eBooks while sitting on a bus, train or plane. I’m enjoying my commute so much more now. I am looking forward to spending even more time in front of my computer screen.
It is many more books out there
A few days ago we shared some interesting data about how much money it takes to make a film. Now let’s look at another side of it – what percentage of books versus movies do you think exist in the world?
There are over 3 billion people in the world today. If you take into account the number of books published every year, it turns out that the total amount of books in the world is around 5.5 trillion. This means that there are many, many more books than films.
Now, obviously, there are a lot of different factors involved here. For example, the quality of writing varies greatly across genres. Some authors write novels while others write short stories. However, even taking into consideration all those differences, it still seems like there are way more books than movies.
Movies: Pros
Movies have music
Have you ever watched a movie with no soundtrack? Did you notice how much better it feels? Some people say that the best part of a film is the music; others think that the story itself is what matters most. But there are some scenes where both aspects play equally important roles. And one of those scenes is the romantic one.
The great thing about watching movies with a full orchestra playing is that you feel like you are actually experiencing something. You hear the music and you see the actors performing live, and that makes you believe that this could really happen. So why don’t we do the same thing with books? Why don’t we add songs to our stories?
When I read a book, sometimes I listen to the music while reading. When I’m writing, I often put my headphones on to block out distractions. This way, I can focus completely on my work. But even though I know that listening to music helps me concentrate, I still find myself doing it anyway.
I’ve noticed that when I’m working on a project, I tend to prefer having background noise over silence. Even if I’m sitting alone in my room, I’ll turn on my computer and start typing away. Sometimes I’ll even keep the volume up high enough that I can barely hear anything else around me. But when I stop for a moment and take off my headphones, everything becomes silent again.
And this happens every time. Every single time. I look down at my phone and realize that I haven’t heard a song since I took off my headphones. What happened? Where did the music go? How am I supposed to write now?
Of course, it doesn’t always happen like this. There are times when I’m working on something quiet, and I decide to switch on Spotify. Then, I notice that I’ve been listening to music for almost half an hour already. I wonder how many hours I spent working without realizing it.
But even though I know that music helps me concentrate, this never stops happening. Whenever I want to write, I’ll turn on the radio or my favorite playlist and start working. And even though I know that it’s distracting, I still end up doing it.
Movies unite people socially, books are rarely read in a group
Reading a book is an individual activity. People like to read alone; they don’t really enjoy being around others while they do it. They prefer to watch movies in groups, however, because they often include interactions such as talking, laughing, and sharing popcorn. In fact, many people go to the movies specifically to spend time with friends.
Most of the people want to watch a movie on a couch with a hot drink, and they usually choose to do it with someone else. Movies are mostly about social interaction, whereas books are generally solitary activities. This is why most people choose to see movies with their friends rather than reading books on their own.
Movies are helpful for those who can’t or aren’t very good at reading
There are quite a lot of things you might not know about someone else. You don’t know what they like, how they feel, what makes them happy or sad, etc. But there are certain things we all do know about each other. We know whether we like sports, music, food, art, etc. And we know if we want to learn something specific – like how to play guitar, speak Spanish or dance. So why is it so difficult to tell if someone likes books or movies?
Here’s one thing most people probably think about books: they enjoy reading them. But it turns out that many people love movies too. In fact, some people even say that watching movies is easier than reading books. This isn’t surprising since movies are usually short, easy to follow and mostly entertaining. On the other hand, novels require concentration and often take several hours to finish.
So does this mean that no one ever reads anything anymore? Not really. Many people still enjoy reading books, especially older ones. But there are plenty of others who prefer movies over books. Why? Because they can watch them whenever they want, wherever they go and without having to worry about getting distracted.
Of course, there are lots of reasons why someone might prefer movies over books. For example, maybe they simply don’t like reading. Or perhaps they find reading boring. Maybe they’re allergic to paper. Or maybe they just enjoy watching movies more. Whatever the case, it doesn’t matter because there are plenty of people who enjoy both books and movies.
Movies are great for people who are not fond of reading
Books vs Movies
I personally know a dozen of people who just don’t enjoy reading books. They prefer watching movies. And it turns out that they’re good at both.
The book format doesn’t appeal to them. It’s too slow. They feel bored.
But movies, on the other end, draw them in. They find it exciting. It’s fast paced.
This group of people is usually into watching documentaries.
The movie is 2 hours long, the book is much longer
In today’s world, it seems like everyone has a busy schedule. From working fulltime jobs to being a parent, there are tons of things competing for our attention. For most people, reading a book takes a lot of time and effort. But what happens when you want to read something quick and easy? If you’re looking for something short and sweet, you might find yourself drawn to a movie. While a movie is definitely shorter than a book, it doesn’t necessarily mean that it’s easier to consume. In fact, the opposite is true. Here are just a few reasons why a movie is better than a book.
1. Time
A movie usually lasts around two hours, whereas a book can easily go over 300 pages. This means that if you wanted to read a book in one sitting, you could spend upwards of five hours doing so. On the other hand, a movie only needs to run for two hours.
2. Energy
While you could probably finish a book in one sitting without getting too tired, a movie requires energy throughout the entire viewing experience. There’s no way to sneakily fall asleep during a movie, either.
3. Focus
If you’ve ever tried to read a book while simultaneously trying to do something else, you know how difficult it can be. Reading a book is a slow process because you have to focus on every word. When watching a movie, however, you can multitask and still keep track of what’s happening.
IMDb vs Goodreads
Vocativ analyzed Goodreads reviews and IMDb ratings for over 800 books and their movie adaptation ranging from Harry Potter to Hannibal. We found that the average rating for the book was much higher than the average rating for the film version. In fact, books are rated “better” on our scale in 51.8% of cases.
The book version of each story received a rating of 74%, while the film’s score was 63%. This is consistent across genres, including science fiction/fantasy (73%), mystery/thriller (74%) and romance (75%).
We also looked at how well the book does compared to the movie. For example, we thought it would be interesting to see how many times the book outperforms the movie. Here’s what we found:
• A whopping 47% of the time, the book is rated “Much Better” than the movie.
• Only 10% of the time, do the book and movie versions perform equally.
• And finally, 33% of the time, it’s the movie that performs better than the book.
Conclusion
Books are great. Movies are even better. But books and movies aren’t the same thing.
The most obvious difference is that you read a book. You see a movie.
But there’s another big one. A book takes longer to watch than it does to read.
A book is long enough that you want to take breaks while reading it. And those breaks are important. They give you space to think about what you’re reading.
You don’t do that when watching a movie. So you miss out on some of the best parts of the story.
And here’s something else. When you finish a book, you feel like you’ve experienced everything the author had to offer.
When you finish a movie, you feel like you missed out on something.
That’s why we recommend that people start with books. Then move on to movies.
Leave a Reply